hip-0018

HIP-18: Payment Processing Standard. Status Draft. Hanzo's own standard — read this before implementing against it.

HIP-0018: Payment Processing Standard

Abstract

This proposal defines the payment processing standard for the Hanzo ecosystem. Hanzo Commerce is the billing, subscription, and payment service that bridges the native Hanzo PSP (Hanzo Pay — the same payment engine white-labeled as lux-pay on Lux and per-brand elsewhere) with the internal credit system managed by Hanzo IAM (HIP-26). Card data is tokenized inside the Hanzo Vault PCI CDE; on-chain rails settle $AI directly. Every dollar a user pays is converted into credits. Every AI inference, API call, or compute job consumes credits. Commerce handles the money side; IAM holds the balance; the LLM Gateway (HIP-4) and Cloud services meter usage.

No external-processor dependency. First-party Hanzo/Lux/Zoo/Zen surfaces process payments through the native PSP, never through a third-party processor that can deplatform us. Commerce keeps a pluggable provider-adapter interface so a brand MAY add a regional rail, but no first-party flow depends on one.

The system is designed around a single invariant: IAM is the source of truth for user balances. Commerce writes credits in; Cloud and Gateway write credits out. No service other than IAM may directly mutate a user's balance. All mutations flow through IAM's transaction API.

Repository: github.com/hanzoai/commerce Port: 4242 Docker: ghcr.io/hanzoai/commerce:latest

The native PSP (Hanzo Pay, the same engine white-labeled as lux-pay / per-brand) provides:

The compliance burden the standard once cited as a reason to outsource (PCI DSS: 300+ controls across 12 categories) is met by scoping the CDE to Hanzo Vault alone, not by handing the customer relationship to a party that can revoke it.

Pluggable Provider Adapters (Optional, Per-Brand)

Commerce keeps a provider-adapter interface so a brand MAY plug an additional rail (regional cards, bank transfer, a Merchant-of-Record for EU VAT, etc.). These are optional, per-brand, and never on a first-party critical path — the native PSP is always the default and the only rail a first-party surface is required to support. Adapters are registered explicitly; none is implicit or default. (Notably, no first-party surface registers an external processor that can deplatform the ecosystem.)

Why Not Blockchain-Only Payments

The Hanzo ecosystem includes $AI token (HIP-1) and on-chain settlement (HIP-25). Why not use blockchain for all payments?

  1. Friction: Most developers do not have crypto wallets. Requiring wallet setup, token purchase, and gas fees for a $20 credit top-up would eliminate 90%+ of potential users.
  2. Volatility: Token prices fluctuate. If a user buys credits with $AI at $0.50 and the price drops to $0.30 before they use the credits, who absorbs the loss?
  3. Speed: The native PSP processes a card payment in 2-3 seconds. On-chain settlement takes 2-15 seconds depending on the chain and requires block confirmations for finality.
  4. Chargebacks: Card users have dispute rights. Blockchain transactions are irreversible. Offering only crypto payments forfeits consumer protection, which is a regulatory risk.

The correct approach is both: the native PSP for fiat, blockchain for crypto. Commerce accepts both and normalizes them into credits. The user does not need to know or care which payment rail was used.

Specification

Architecture

                              +------------------------+
                              |  Hanzo Pay (native PSP)|
                              |  + Hanzo Vault (PCI    |
                              |   CDE: card tokens)    |
                              |  Checkout/Billing/Hooks|
                              +------+------+----------+
                                     |      |
                           webhooks  |      |  checkout sessions
                                     |      |
                              +------v------v----------+
                              |    Hanzo Commerce      |
                              |    (payment logic)     |
                              |      :4242             |
                              +------+--------+--------+
                                     |        |
                      +--------------+--------+-------------+
                      |              |                      |
               add-balance    add-transaction          get-account
                      |              |                      |
                      v              v                      v
               +----------------------------------------------+
               |           Hanzo IAM (HIP-26)                 |
               |     (user balances, transactions)            |
               |            hanzo.id :8000                    |
               +----------------------------------------------+
                      ^              ^
                      |              |
               token validation  debit transactions
                      |              |
         +------------+-+     +------+----------+
         |  LLM Gateway |     |   Hanzo Cloud   |
         |   (HIP-4)    |     |  (compute jobs) |
         |    :4000      |     |                 |
         +--------------+     +-----------------+

Credit System

Credit Definition

| Property | Value | |----------|-------| | Unit name | credit | | USD value | 1 credit = $0.001 USD | | Minimum purchase | 1,000 credits ($1.00) | | Maximum single purchase | 10,000,000 credits ($10,000) | | Precision | Integer (no fractional credits) | | Storage | float64 in IAM user balance field (USD-denominated) |

Credits are stored as a USD-denominated float in IAM (1,000 credits = $1.00 balance). The "credit" is a user-facing abstraction; the IAM balance field stores the dollar equivalent. This means 20,000 credits = $20.00 balance.

Credit Pricing Tiers

Bulk purchases receive volume discounts:

| Purchase Amount | Credits | Bonus | Effective Rate | |----------------|---------|-------|----------------| | $5 | 5,000 | 0% | $0.001/credit | | $20 | 21,000 | 5% | $0.000952/credit | | $50 | 55,000 | 10% | $0.000909/credit | | $100 | 115,000 | 15% | $0.000870/credit | | $500 | 600,000 | 20% | $0.000833/credit | | $1,000+ | Custom | 25%+ | Negotiated |

AI Usage Credit Costs

Credit costs are derived from provider pricing plus a margin. The LLM Gateway publishes a rate card:

| Operation | Model Tier | Credits | Approx. USD | |-----------|-----------|---------|-------------| | Chat completion (1K input tokens) | Economy (Mixtral, Llama) | 1 | $0.001 | | Chat completion (1K input tokens) | Standard (GPT-4-Turbo, Claude Sonnet) | 10 | $0.01 | | Chat completion (1K input tokens) | Premium (GPT-4, Claude Opus) | 30 | $0.03 | | Chat completion (1K output tokens) | Economy | 2 | $0.002 | | Chat completion (1K output tokens) | Standard | 15 | $0.015 | | Chat completion (1K output tokens) | Premium | 60 | $0.06 | | Image generation (1024x1024) | DALL-E 3 | 40 | $0.04 | | Embedding (1K tokens) | text-embedding-3-small | 0.1 | $0.0001 | | Audio transcription (1 minute) | Whisper | 6 | $0.006 | | Computer use (1 action) | Operative | 5 | $0.005 |

These rates are stored in the LLM Gateway configuration and updated when provider pricing changes. Commerce does not need to know the rates; it only processes the debit transactions that Gateway and Cloud submit to IAM.

Subscription Tiers

tiers:
  free:
    name: "Free"
    price_monthly: 0
    credits_monthly: 1000
    psp_price_id: null
    overage: blocked
    features:
      - "1,000 credits/month (~100 GPT-4 messages)"
      - "Community support"
      - "3 requests/minute rate limit"
      - "Standard models only"

  pro:
    name: "Pro"
    price_monthly: 20
    credits_monthly: 50000
    psp_price_id: "price_pro_monthly"
    overage: pay_as_you_go
    features:
      - "50,000 credits/month (~5,000 GPT-4 messages)"
      - "Priority support"
      - "60 requests/minute rate limit"
      - "All models including Premium tier"
      - "MCP tool access"
      - "Usage analytics dashboard"

  team:
    name: "Team"
    price_monthly: 100
    credits_monthly: 150000
    psp_price_id: "price_team_monthly"
    overage: pay_as_you_go
    features:
      - "150,000 credits/month"
      - "5 team members included ($15/additional)"
      - "Shared org billing"
      - "120 requests/minute rate limit"
      - "Admin dashboard"
      - "SSO via IAM (HIP-26)"

  enterprise:
    name: "Enterprise"
    price_monthly: custom
    credits_monthly: custom
    psp_price_id: "price_enterprise_custom"
    overage: invoice
    features:
      - "Custom credit allocation"
      - "Unlimited team members"
      - "Dedicated support and SLA"
      - "Custom rate limits"
      - "Volume discounts (25%+)"
      - "Invoice billing (NET 30)"
      - "SOC 2 compliance reports"

Free-tier credits reset monthly and do not accumulate. Paid-tier included credits roll over for 90 days. Purchased credits (one-time top-ups) never expire.

Subscription Lifecycle

Payment Flow

One-Time Credit Purchase (Fiat)

1. Client: POST /v1/billing/checkout { amount: 2000, currency: "usd", credits: 21000 }
2. Commerce creates a PSP checkout session with metadata (user_id, org_id, credits, idempotency_key)
3. Commerce returns checkout URL -> client redirects user to the native hosted checkout
4. User completes payment on the native hosted checkout page (Hanzo Vault CDE)
5. PSP fires webhook: checkout.session.completed
6. Commerce verifies webhook signature (HMAC-SHA256)
7. Commerce checks idempotency key in KV (prevent double-processing)
8. Commerce calls IAM: POST /api/add-balance { owner: "hanzo", user: "z", amount: 21.0 }
9. Commerce records transaction: POST /api/add-transaction
   { category: "Recharge", user: "z", amount: 21.0, name: "txn_psp_cs_..." }
10. User's IAM balance updated. Credits available immediately.

Crypto Payment Flow ($AI Token)

Commerce also accepts $AI token (HIP-1) payments on Hanzo Network (chain ID 36963). The user sends tokens to a per-user deposit address. Commerce's on-chain listener detects the Transfer event (1 block confirmation for <$1K, 6 for >=$1K), converts $AI to USD at the 10-minute TWAP oracle rate via HMM (HIP-8), and credits the user's IAM balance through the same add-balance/add-transaction flow as fiat.

Billing API Endpoints

| Method | Endpoint | Description | Auth | |--------|----------|-------------|------| | GET | /v1/billing/balance | Current credit balance | Bearer token | | GET | /v1/billing/transactions | Transaction history with pagination | Bearer token | | POST | /v1/billing/checkout | Create PSP checkout session | Bearer token | | POST | /v1/billing/checkout/crypto | Create crypto payment intent | Bearer token | | POST | /v1/billing/subscribe | Create or change subscription | Bearer token | | DELETE | /v1/billing/subscribe | Cancel subscription | Bearer token | | GET | /v1/billing/subscription | Current subscription details | Bearer token | | GET | /v1/billing/invoices | List invoices | Bearer token | | GET | /v1/billing/invoices/:id | Download invoice PDF | Bearer token | | GET | /v1/billing/usage | Usage breakdown by period | Bearer token | | POST | /v1/billing/portal | Create PSP customer portal session | Bearer token | | POST | /webhooks/psp | PSP webhook receiver | PSP signature |

Response Examples

GET /v1/billing/balance returns the user's current credit state:

{
  "balance": 15420, "balance_usd": 15.42, "tier": "pro",
  "credits_included": 50000, "credits_used": 34580, "credits_remaining": 15420,
  "period_start": "2026-02-01T00:00:00Z", "period_end": "2026-03-01T00:00:00Z",
  "auto_recharge": { "enabled": true, "threshold": 1000, "amount": 20000 }
}

GET /v1/billing/transactions returns paginated transaction history. Each transaction includes id, timestamp, category (Purchase/Recharge), credits (negative for debits), balance_after, and metadata with model/token/provider details.

GET /v1/billing/usage?period=2026-02 returns usage aggregated by model (gpt-4-turbo, claude-3-sonnet, etc.), by service (llm-gateway, cloud, mcp), and optionally by day when granularity=daily is specified.

Webhook Handling

Commerce receives webhooks from the native PSP for all payment-related events. The webhook handler follows a strict pipeline:

async def handle_psp_webhook(request):
    # 1. Verify signature (CRITICAL - prevents forgery)
    payload = request.body
    signature = request.headers["X-Webhook-Signature"]
    try:
        event = psp.verify_event(
            payload, signature, psp_webhook_secret
        )
    except psp.SignatureError:
        return Response(status=400, body="Invalid signature")

    # 2. Check idempotency (prevent double-processing)
    event_id = event["id"]
    if await redis.exists(f"webhook:processed:{event_id}"):
        return Response(status=200, body="Already processed")

    # 3. Route by event type
    handlers = {
        "checkout.session.completed": handle_checkout_completed,
        "invoice.paid": handle_invoice_paid,
        "invoice.payment_failed": handle_payment_failed,
        "customer.subscription.updated": handle_subscription_updated,
        "customer.subscription.deleted": handle_subscription_deleted,
        "charge.dispute.created": handle_dispute_created,
        "charge.refunded": handle_refund,
    }
    handler = handlers.get(event["type"])
    if handler:
        await handler(event)

    # 4. Mark as processed (72h TTL matching the PSP retry window)
    await redis.set(f"webhook:processed:{event_id}", "1", ex=259200)

    return Response(status=200)

Handled Webhook Events

| Event | Action | |-------|--------| | checkout.session.completed | Add credits to user's IAM balance | | invoice.paid | Add subscription credits; record payment | | invoice.payment_failed | Send warning email; flag account | | customer.subscription.updated | Update tier in IAM user properties | | customer.subscription.deleted | Downgrade to Free tier | | charge.dispute.created | Freeze account; debit disputed amount; create support ticket | | charge.dispute.closed | Unfreeze if won; maintain debit if lost | | charge.refunded | Debit refunded credits from IAM balance |

Usage Metering

The LLM Gateway and Cloud services do not interact with Commerce directly for debits. They submit usage to IAM via the transaction API:

LLM Gateway receives request
    |
    +-- 1. Validate JWT (IAM)
    +-- 2. Check balance from JWT claims or /api/get-account
    +-- 3. If insufficient balance: return 402 Payment Required
    +-- 4. Execute LLM request (provider API)
    +-- 5. Calculate cost:
    |      input_tokens * input_rate + output_tokens * output_rate
    |      -> convert to USD -> round to credits
    +-- 6. Submit debit transaction to IAM:
    |      POST /api/add-transaction
    |      {
    |        "category": "Purchase",
    |        "user": "<user>",
    |        "amount": -0.012,    // negative = debit
    |        "detail": "gpt-4-turbo: 847 in + 400 out tokens"
    |      }
    +-- 7. Return response to user

The Gateway batches transaction submissions. Rather than calling IAM for every request, it accumulates usage per user over a 10-second window and submits a single aggregated transaction. This reduces IAM load by ~90% during high-throughput periods.

metering:
  batch_interval: 10s
  batch_max_size: 100
  minimum_charge: 0.001       # 1 credit minimum debit
  balance_check: jwt_claims   # or "api_call"
  insufficient_balance_code: 402
  retry_on_iam_failure: true
  retry_max_attempts: 3
  retry_backoff: exponential

Multi-Organization Billing

Each organization in IAM has independent billing. A user who belongs to multiple organizations (e.g., z@hanzo.ai is a member of both hanzo and zoo) has a separate balance in each organization context.

Organization: hanzo
  User: z
    Balance: $150.00
    Tier: Enterprise
    Transactions: [org-scoped]

Organization: zoo
  User: z
    Balance: $25.00
    Tier: Pro
    Transactions: [org-scoped]

When the LLM Gateway processes a request, the organization context is determined by the OAuth application that issued the token. A token from app-cloud (organization: hanzo) bills against the hanzo org balance. A token from app-zoo bills against the zoo org balance.

Organizations can choose between two billing modes:

Refund and Dispute Handling

Refund Policy

Refund Flow

  1. User requests refund via support or /v1/billing/refund.
  2. Commerce validates eligibility (14-day window, sufficient credit balance).
  3. Commerce creates a refund via the PSP (psp.refunds.create) for the original payment intent.
  4. The PSP processes the refund (3-5 business days to card).
  5. On webhook charge.refunded, Commerce debits the refunded credits from IAM via add-transaction with negative amount.
  6. If the user's balance goes negative after the debit, the account is flagged and usage is suspended until the balance is positive.

Dispute (Chargeback) Flow

  1. The PSP receives a chargeback from the card issuer -> webhook charge.dispute.created.
  2. Commerce immediately freezes the user account (suspended=true in IAM), debits the disputed amount, creates a support ticket, and notifies the admin team.
  3. Commerce submits evidence to the PSP: usage logs, IP addresses, login timestamps, and ToS acceptance.
  4. The card network arbitrates (60-90 days). On charge.dispute.closed: if won, Commerce unfreezes the account and restores the debited amount; if lost, the account remains suspended until the balance is positive.

Invoice Generation

Commerce generates monthly invoices for all users with non-zero activity. Each invoice includes:

Invoices are stored as PDFs in MinIO (HIP-32) and emailed to the user. Enterprise customers on Net-30 receive invoices with payment instructions instead of automatic billing.

Auto-Recharge

Users can configure automatic credit purchases when their balance drops below a threshold:

POST /v1/billing/auto-recharge
Authorization: Bearer <access_token>

{
  "enabled": true,
  "threshold": 1000,
  "amount": 20000,
  "max_monthly": 5,
  "payment_method": "pm_..."
}

When the metering pipeline detects a balance crossing below the threshold, it enqueues an auto-recharge job. The job creates a PSP payment intent using the stored (tokenized) payment method, processes the charge, and credits the balance without user interaction. Auto-recharge is rate-limited (max 5/month by default) to prevent runaway charges from buggy clients or compromised API keys.

Implementation Roadmap

Phase 2: Subscriptions (Completed)

Security Considerations

PCI DSS Compliance

Commerce achieves PCI compliance by never handling cardholder data. Cardholder data is confined to the Hanzo Vault CDE — the only PCI-DSS-scoped component — which hosts the payment form (native hosted checkout) and issues opaque tokens. Commerce and every app server operate on tokens only; they never see, store, process, or transmit card numbers, CVVs, or expiration dates. Commerce qualifies as a SAQ A surface; the Vault carries the full SAQ D / RoC scope, isolated from the rest of the ecosystem.

Webhook Signature Verification

Every native-PSP webhook is verified using HMAC-SHA256:

# The PSP signs webhooks with the webhook signing secret (held in KMS).
# The signature includes a timestamp to prevent replay attacks.
signature = request.headers["X-Webhook-Signature"]
# Format: t=<timestamp>,v1=<signature>

expected = hmac_sha256(
    key=psp_webhook_secret,   # from KMS, never plaintext
    message=f"{timestamp}.{payload}"
)

# Reject if:
# 1. Signature does not match (forged webhook)
# 2. Timestamp is > 300 seconds old (replay attack)
# 3. Event ID already processed (duplicate delivery)

Idempotency

Every payment operation uses idempotency keys to prevent double-charging:

  1. PSP Checkout: The idempotency_key in session metadata ensures retried webhooks do not create duplicate credits.
  2. IAM Transactions: The transaction name field (txn_psp_{event_id}) acts as a unique constraint. IAM rejects duplicate transaction names.
  3. Deduplication store: Processed webhook event IDs are persisted with a 72-hour TTL matching the PSP's retry window.

These three layers provide defense-in-depth against double-processing.

Rate Limiting

| Endpoint | Limit | Window | |----------|-------|--------| | /v1/billing/checkout | 10 | per minute per user | | /v1/billing/subscribe | 5 | per minute per user | | /v1/billing/balance | 60 | per minute per user | | /v1/billing/transactions | 30 | per minute per user | | /v1/billing/usage | 10 | per minute per user | | /webhooks/psp | 1000 | per minute (global) |

Rate limiting is enforced via KV sliding window counters. Exceeding the limit returns 429 Too Many Requests with a Retry-After header.

Audit Trail

Every financial event produces an immutable audit record:

{
  "event_id": "evt_audit_001",
  "timestamp": "2026-02-23T10:30:15.123Z",
  "action": "credit_purchase",
  "actor": {
    "user_id": "hanzo/z",
    "ip": "203.0.113.42",
    "user_agent": "Mozilla/5.0..."
  },
  "details": {
    "psp_event_id": "evt_...",
    "psp_session_id": "cs_...",
    "amount_usd": 20.00,
    "credits_added": 21000,
    "balance_before": 5000,
    "balance_after": 26000,
    "idempotency_key": "ik_abc123"
  },
  "integrity": "sha256:ab3f..."
}

Audit records are append-only (never updated or deleted), integrity-protected with SHA-256 hash chains, retained for 7 years (financial regulatory minimum), and exportable for SOC 2 and compliance audits.

Fraud Prevention

Insufficient Balance Handling

When a user's balance reaches zero during an API request:

  1. The LLM Gateway returns 402 Payment Required with a link to the billing page.
  2. Streaming responses are terminated gracefully -- partial completions are delivered with a final chunk indicating billing exhaustion.
  3. If auto-recharge is enabled, it triggers immediately, and the request can be retried.

References

  1. HIP-1: $AI Token - Native currency for crypto payments
  2. HIP-4: LLM Gateway - Primary usage metering source
  3. HIP-8: HMM (Hanzo Market Maker) - Token price oracle for crypto-to-credit conversion
  4. HIP-25: Bot Agent Wallet & RPC Billing Protocol - Agent-level billing built on Commerce
  5. HIP-26: Identity & Access Management Standard - Balance storage and transaction ledger
  6. HIP-27: Secrets Management Standard - KMS for PSP keys and secrets
  7. HIP-30: Event Streaming Standard - Billing event distribution
  8. HIP-32: Object Storage Standard - Invoice PDF storage
  9. HIP-101: Hanzo-Lux Bridge Protocol - Cross-chain payment acceptance
  10. Hanzo Pay (native PSP) — github.com/lux-pay (white-labeled lux-pay on Lux)
  11. Hanzo Vault — PCI CDE / card tokenization
  12. PCI DSS v4.0 — SAQ A / SAQ D scoping
  13. PCI DSS Quick Reference Guide
  14. Hanzo Commerce Repository

Copyright

Copyright and related rights waived via CC0.